Humans.Inspired.
The Edge of More
Confidence

Turn the Volume Down on Your Inner Critic

A thin-to-thick story practice

Your inner critic may never go away completely. But you can turn down the volume so it's more like a whisper.

Our inner critic tells us stories about our success, and most of them are thin, flimsy and discredit our evidence. The more often we tell a thicker, objective story that's rooted in truth, the quieter the critic gets.

A thin story

The critic's quick, narrow version. It credits luck, a fluke, overwork, or someone else, and leaves you out.

"I just got lucky." "They're just being nice."

A thick story

The fuller, truer version, with your effort, your skills and the context included. Not "I'm amazing." Just the whole picture.

"I was prepared when the opportunity came."

Set aside about 10 minutes. Choose one thin story your critic has been telling you lately and work through four short steps. There are no right answers. Your answers stay private on this device and are saved as you go.

1

Name it

Giving your critic a name creates a little distance. It's a voice, not the truth.
2

Notice it

Catch the thin story, and notice what it's costing you.
3

Respond

Thicken the story

Pause, and choose your response instead of reacting. Add the detail your critic leaves out. Jot a few words beside any question that sparks something. You don't need to answer them all.

Your thin story
See an example
Name it
My critic is The Discounter. Its favourite line: "They're just being nice."
The thin story
When people tell me I'm good at leading and developing a team, I think, "They're just being nice. I had nothing to do with that."
The impact
I brush off feedback, hold back from sharing what I know, and second-guess myself when I'm asked to lead something new.
Thickening it
I've coached people who went on to step into bigger roles. I've built teams that trusted each other and delivered. That took listening, preparation and hard conversations. My team did great work, and I helped create the conditions for it.
The thicker story
"I'm good at developing people. It's something I've practised and built over years, and my teams' growth is real evidence of it. I can share the credit and still own my part."
Reflect
I feel steadier, and more willing to offer what I know. My small step: when someone gives me positive feedback this week, I'll say "thank you" and let it land.

My thicker, truer story

Rewrite the thin story in one to three sentences, using what you discovered.

The thin story

Give it a try first. Your own words matter most. When you're ready, or if you're stuck, see what your answers from the last step are already telling you.

4

Reflect

Notice what the thicker story opens up.

Your thin-to-thick story

Keep this somewhere you'll see it. The next time your critic gets loud, come back to the thicker story.

Feeling like an imposter doesn't mean you are one. Each thicker story turns the volume down a little more.
Credit. Adapted from the Thickening the Narrative Tool (Module 2: Transforming Triggers and Stories), Imposter Syndrome Coach Practitioner program, Dr. Lisa Orbé-Austin, Coaching.com © 2025. Used by Alison Hamilton, Certified Imposter Syndrome Coach Practitioner. This practice is for personal reflection and growth and isn't a substitute for professional support. If it brings up something heavy, please reach out to someone you trust or a qualified professional.